ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsOhio › Grove City

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Grove City, OH

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Grove City, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Grove City, Ohio is Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC, rated 4.9 stars across 323 reviews. Other highly rated options include Zach Moore - State Farm Insurance Agent, Mitchell Insurance Agency, HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader. This directory lists 19 medicare insurance agents serving Grove City.

Showing 19 medicare insurance agents in Grove City, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC4213 Hoover Rd(614) 259-5000
2Zach Moore - State Farm Insurance Agent1616 Gateway Cir(614) 875-1893
3Mitchell Insurance Agency2204 Stringtown Rd(614) 875-1770
4HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader3826 Broadway(614) 277-8440
5Trent Karlson - State Farm Insurance Agent3387 McDowell Rd(614) 875-2563
6Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC1596 Stringtown Rd(614) 277-3650
7Gary Snowden - State Farm Insurance Agent3043 Turnberry Ct(614) 801-2000
8Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle3897 Grove City Rd B(614) 277-8916
9Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency4200 Hoover Rd Suite A(614) 871-9707
10Western & Southern Life1953 Ohio Dr(614) 277-4800
SI
4213 Hoover Rd
Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Shepherd Insurance Partners, INC serves clients in and around Grove City, Ohio, helping individuals and families navigate Medicare insurance options. As a local Medicare insurance agent, it assists with plan selection during enrollment periods and offers guidance on coverage choices. This agency addresses Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Supplement plans. It also helps clients review Part D prescription drug coverage available in the area.

ZM
1616 Gateway Cir
Zach Moore - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Zach Moore - State Farm Insurance Agent in Grove City, OH, provides Medicare insurance guidance to help individuals understand their coverage options. The agency assists with plan comparisons and enrollment for the part of health coverage designed for older adults. It also offers ongoing support for policy maintenance and annual review of plan changes. This service is available to those living in single-family homes, apartments, and retirement communities throughout the surrounding area.

MI
2204 Stringtown Rd
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency in Grove City, Ohio serves seniors and individuals approaching Medicare eligibility who need help navigating their health coverage options. The agency assists clients in selecting Medicare Advantage, prescription drug, and Medigap supplemental plans that fit their healthcare needs and budgets. It explains the differences between plan types, including costs, network restrictions, and out-of-pocket protections. The agency also provides ongoing support during enrollment and annual open enrollment periods. Coverage is available for residents in neighboring Columbus and throughout the southern Franklin County metro communities.

HI
3826 Broadway
HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

HealthMarkets Insurance - Dan Schrader serves local homeowners and families seeking to understand their Medicare options. The agency guides individuals through Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D drug plan choices, helping to match coverage with healthcare needs and budgets. Clients receive personalized assistance during enrollment periods and ongoing support for plan questions or changes. Based in Grove City, Ohio, the agency also covers nearby Columbus and the surrounding Franklin County communities.

TK
3387 McDowell Rd
Trent Karlson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Serving Grove City and the surrounding central Ohio communities, Trent Karlson - State Farm Insurance Agent handles Medicare insurance enrollment and plan options for eligible local residents. The agency focuses on explaining the differences between Medicare Parts A, B, C, and D, including supplemental coverage. Each client session begins with a straightforward review of individual healthcare needs and current coverage, comparing available plans to find a suitable fit. This approach breaks down the complex enrollment process step by step throughout the entire consultation.

NI
1596 Stringtown Rd
Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Nationwide Insurance: Eggleston Insurance & Financial Group LLC in Grove City, Ohio helps individuals understand the difference between one-time annual enrollment changes and recurring coverage management for Medicare insurance. They clarify initial plan selection and detail the available Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D prescription drug options for local residents. Each year during specified enrollment periods, clients may reassess their needs without penalty. This agent provides service on both a one-time consultation basis for those enrolling for the first time and on an as-needed basis for ongoing plan review and adjustments.

GS
3043 Turnberry Ct
Gary Snowden - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Gary Snowden - State Farm Insurance Agent in Grove City, OH specializes in Medicare insurance plans, including Medigap and Medicare Advantage options. The agency helps local seniors understand their coverage choices during initial enrollment and annual election periods. General services include reviewing prescription drug plans and coordinating benefits with existing health coverage. The office assists clients with the complexities of navigating plan changes while avoiding late enrollment penalties. It specifically helps retirees and those turning sixty-five evaluate their options each fall during the Medicare Open Enrollment period.

SI
3897 Grove City Rd B
Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

As residents of Grove City consider their upcoming Medicare options during open enrollment, Shelter Insurance - Matthew Castle offers guidance through plan comparisons and coverage updates for those turning sixty-five or reassessing existing policies. The agency clarifies differences between Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans, addressing common concerns about prescription drug coverage and out-of-pocket costs. Clients receive personalized explanations about how various plans coordinate with original Medicare. The process typically begins with a free initial consultation to review current medical needs and prescription usage, determining which available local plans merit further inspection.

LG
4200 Hoover Rd Suite A
Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Leavitt Group Midwest Insurance Agency in Grove City, Ohio, assists clients with navigating Medicare plan options. The firm specializes in helping people understand their choices during open enrollment periods. It provides guidance on comparing plans to support informed decisions about healthcare coverage. The agency can address the insurance needs of office staff, those working in warehouses, and personnel involved in food service operations.

WS
1953 Ohio Dr
Western & Southern Life
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH

Western & Southern Life serves residents in Grove City, Ohio, with Medicare insurance guidance, helping individuals select suitable plans for their health needs. While primarily focused on residential clients, the company also assists with commercial coverage options where applicable, extending its service throughout the local area. Their agents explain coverage details and enrollment periods in straightforward terms. After a plan is in place, the team follows up on claims questions or coverage changes and provides ongoing support between regular annual enrollment visits.

MP
3907 Broadway
Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 871-1200
mpbins.com
CA
3011 Columbus St #202
Chuck Auber Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 991-5184
chuckauberinsurance.com
JC
2598 Columbus St
Jorge Carbonell: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 801-2091
agents.allstate.com/jorge-carbonell-grove-city-oh.html
BE
3848 Broadway
Bennett ~ Edgar Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 871-3200
bennettedgarins.com
EA
3821 Broadway B
Emily Allen American Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 871-8729
amfam.com/agents/ohio/grove-city/emily-allen
FI
3886 Broadway
Farmers Insurance - Nickolas Perini
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 875-1907
agents.farmers.com/oh/grove-city/nickolas-perini
AI
3444B Broadway
Allstate Insurance Agent: Erica Dimmerling
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 845-0578
agents.allstate.com/erica-dimmerling-grove-city-oh.html
BR
1608 Gateway Cir
Brian Roberts - Farmers Insurance Agents
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 539-5000
SI
3971 Hoover Rd Box 133
Speakman Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Grove City, OH
(614) 946-4665
speakmaninsurance.com

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Grove City Cost?

Medicare insurance agent services in Ohio are generally free to consumers because agents earn commissions from insurance carriers. Plan costs vary: Medicare Part B premiums are standard at $174.70 per month in 2024, while Medicare Advantage plans may have $0 monthly premiums or up to $200 or more. Medigap policies in Ohio range from about $100 to $300 per month depending on age and plan type. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Grove City

Residents of Grove City, Ohio can work with a licensed Medicare insurance agent to compare plans and understand their coverage options. Ohio law requires agents to be certified by the Ohio Department of Insurance and to follow specific marketing guidelines. A local agent can help you navigate Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D plans available in Franklin County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Grove City do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you review and compare Medicare plans, including Medicare Advantage and Medigap policies. They explain coverage details, costs, and provider networks specific to the Grove City area. Agents are licensed and must follow Ohio insurance regulations.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Ohio?

Your Initial Enrollment Period begins three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Ohio also has an Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year. Special Enrollment Periods may apply if you lose other coverage or move.

Are Medicare insurance agent services free in Ohio?

Most Medicare insurance agents are paid by insurance companies through commissions, so their services are typically free to you. Ohio law requires agents to disclose any compensation they receive. Always confirm that there are no direct fees before working with an agent.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.