ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Portage, WI

Browse home insurance agents serving Portage, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Portage, Wisconsin is Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance, rated 4.8 stars across 86 reviews. Other highly rated options include Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance, TRICOR Insurance, Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance. This directory lists 13 home insurance agents serving Portage.

Showing 13 home insurance agents in Portage, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance1606 New Pinery Rd Ste B(608) 742-3888
2Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance214 W Cook St(608) 742-6548
3TRICOR Insurance236 W Cook St(608) 742-5548
4Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance131 W Cook St(608) 742-3999
5Sean Malone - State Farm Insurance Agent415 W Wisconsin St(608) 742-6754
6Miller Simonson Insurance118 W Collins St(608) 745-4665
7Okray Insurance Agency LLC2555 New Pinery Rd(608) 742-5560
8Evolution Agency2559 New Pinery Rd(608) 745-4680
9Armor Insurance Services LLC141 E Cook St(608) 745-9144
10Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Brad Damon201 DeWitt St #C1(608) 742-4444
RK
1606 New Pinery Rd Ste B
Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance serves the Portage, Wisconsin area as a home insurance agent. The agency offers standard residential policies that protect structures and personal belongings against common perils such as fire, theft, and weather damage. Coverage options are tailored to meet the needs of local homeowners, including those in newer developments and older established neighborhoods. The agency also handles renters insurance for tenants and helps clients understand policy deductibles and liability limits.

SC
214 W Cook St
Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

As a home insurance agent in Portage, WI, Shelly Cibulka: Allstate Insurance provides a range of coverage options tailored to protect residential and commercial properties. The agency offers guidance on structuring policies to fit individual needs and reviews plans during regular maintenance check-ins to help ensure adequate coverage over time. Its service approach includes answering questions about claims processes and helping clients adjust their policies as life circumstances change. She services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

TI
236 W Cook St
TRICOR Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

TRICOR Insurance provides home insurance services in Portage, Wisconsin, and the surrounding communities in Columbia County. It handles coverage for single-family homes and rental properties. The agency assists clients in assessing their property's unique risks, such as local weather patterns and construction materials. It then reviews policy options to match those specific needs. To handle a typical job, TRICOR Insurance begins with a thorough consultation and follows up by comparing multiple carriers to find appropriate protection.

SL
131 W Cook St
Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Sheila Link Agency Inc American Family Insurance serves Portage, Wisconsin, and the surrounding Columbia County communities. The home insurance agent handles policies for single-family homes, condominiums, and rental properties across the region. Each policy is tailored by assessing specific property risks and local weather patterns. To complete a typical job, the agent conducts an initial needs review, then combines coverage options that align with the homeowner’s budget and property type.

SM
415 W Wisconsin St
Sean Malone - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Sean Malone - State Farm Insurance Agent serves homeowners, landlords, and small businesses in Portage and the surrounding area, offering home insurance policies tailored to protect property and personal assets from local risks such as severe weather and liability concerns. The agency works with customers to review coverage needs, explain policy options, and provide claims assistance when damage occurs. It also extends its services to property owners in nearby communities like Pardeeville and the broader Columbia County region, making coverage accessible across the area.

MS
118 W Collins St
Miller Simonson Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Miller Simonson Insurance offers home insurance solutions tailored for both one-time policy placements and recurring annual renewals, providing flexible service options for Portage homeowners. Coverage focuses on protecting dwellings and personal property against common local risks such as severe storms, fire, and liability claims. As a home insurance agent, the company helps clients assess their unique needs and select appropriate policy limits. Service for policy adjustments, claims assistance, and annual reviews is available on both a scheduled and as-needed basis.

OI
2555 New Pinery Rd
Okray Insurance Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Okray Insurance Agency LLC in Portage, WI specializes in tailoring home insurance policies to protect both the structure of a home and the personal belongings within it. The agency assists local residents in evaluating coverage limits, deductibles, and additional endorsements to match their specific property needs. It also advises on liability protection and discounts for safety features. During the harsh Wisconsin winter, the agency helps homeowners address concerns related to ice dam damage and frozen pipe claims.

EA
2559 New Pinery Rd
Evolution Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

As winter approaches in Portage, homeowners often worry about ice dams and frozen pipes. Evolution Agency provides home insurance coverage that addresses these seasonal risks specific to south-central Wisconsin. They work to match policies with the region's fluctuating weather patterns, protecting both older homes near the Wisconsin River and newer developments. Their process begins with a thorough assessment of the property’s current condition and exposure to local hazards. This initial inspection helps tailor the coverage to the homeowner's unique needs before any policy is finalized.

AI
141 E Cook St
Armor Insurance Services LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Armor Insurance Services LLC provides home insurance solutions for residential properties in Portage and the surrounding area. Commercial insurance coverage is also available for local businesses in need of protection. The agency works with clients to select appropriate policies tailored to individual property and liability needs, offering guidance through the selection process. Clients are encouraged to follow up for periodic policy reviews or adjustments between regular visits, ensuring their coverage remains suitable as circumstances evolve.

RM
201 DeWitt St #C1
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Brad Damon
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI

Located in Portage, WI, this agency provides home insurance to protect local households from common Midwest risks. Brad Damon of Rural Mutual specializes in tailoring policies to cover valuable personal property, liability, and additional living expenses after a covered loss. Standard protection can be enhanced with endorsements for equipment breakdown or identity fraud coverage. The agency also serves business clients, offering commercial policies for offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

FI
2910 New Pinery Rd Ste A
Farmers Insurance - Gary Witt
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 745-1547
agents.farmers.com/wi/portage/gary-witt
CE
109 W Cook St
Cutting Edge Insurance Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 697-8282
cuttingedgeinsurancewi.com/contact
WA
2910 New Pinery Rd
Witt Agency LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Portage, WI
(608) 745-1547
agents.farmers.com/wi/portage/gary-witt

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Portage Cost?

Typical home insurance costs in Wisconsin range from 800 to 1,500 dollars per year for a standard policy. Rates in Portage may be slightly higher due to local weather risks. Factors like home age and coverage limits affect the final price. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Portage

Home insurance agents in Portage Wisconsin help homeowners protect their property and assets. Wisconsin law requires insurers to offer specific coverages like wind and hail. Local agents can explain policy options and help you find a plan that fits your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Portage do?

A home insurance agent in Portage helps you compare policies from different companies. They explain coverage types such as dwelling, liability, and personal property. They also assist with claims and policy changes.

Is home insurance required in Wisconsin?

Home insurance is not legally required by Wisconsin state law. However, mortgage lenders typically require it. Without insurance, you risk financial loss from fire, storm, or theft.

What factors affect home insurance cost in Portage?

Costs depend on your home value, age, location, and claims history. Wisconsin weather risks like hail and snow also impact rates. Your credit score and deductible choice can change the premium.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.