ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Carlisle, PA

Browse home insurance agents serving Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Carlisle, Pennsylvania is Jon Fetterman - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 169 reviews. Other highly rated options include Greg Lunde - State Farm Insurance Agent, Mike Shope - State Farm Insurance Agent, AAA Central Penn. This directory lists 11 home insurance agents serving Carlisle.

Showing 11 home insurance agents in Carlisle, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Jon Fetterman - State Farm Insurance Agent805 E High St(717) 249-4251
2Greg Lunde - State Farm Insurance Agent11 State Ave(717) 241-2341
3Mike Shope - State Farm Insurance Agent812 W High St(717) 241-3029
4AAA Central Penn1911 W Trindle Rd #1(800) 421-4552
5Miller Carlisle Insurance Services19 Brookwood Ave #102(717) 243-4400
6Dan Collison - State Farm Agent22 S Hanover St(717) 249-1582
7Deibler Insurance Associates26 Westminster Dr(717) 241-2775
8Grove Financial &Associates, Inc.155 W High St(717) 243-6877
9Insurance Connections / Benefit Connections - aka The Kole Group43 Eastgate Dr Suite 100(717) 258-5599
10Douglas E. Garrity Insurance1786 Newville Rd(717) 243-3467
JF
805 E High St
Jon Fetterman - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Jon Fetterman - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Carlisle, Pennsylvania area as a home insurance agent. This office helps local homeowners secure policies that protect their property and personal belongings from common risks. An agent can guide clients through coverage options such as dwelling protection. The agency also assists with insurance for renters who lease a residence. Specific services handled in this area include advising on replacement cost coverage and offering personal liability protection.

GL
11 State Ave
Greg Lunde - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Greg Lunde - State Farm Insurance Agent provides a wide range of home insurance services for property owners in the Carlisle, PA area. The agency handles policy consultations and provides appraisal support to help ensure adequate coverage. It offers routine policy reviews and guidance on adjusting deductibles to match changing needs. The agent serves single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants throughout the local community.

MS
812 W High St
Mike Shope - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Mike Shope - State Farm Insurance Agent in Carlisle, PA, serves homeowners, rental property owners, and local businesses by providing standard home insurance policies. The agency explains basic coverage for dwelling, personal property, and liability exposures common to central Pennsylvania properties. Services include policy reviews, claims filing assistance, and guidance on deductibles or replacement cost options. Customers in nearby communities such as Mechanicsburg or along the Route 11 corridor also receive support from this location.

AC
1911 W Trindle Rd #1
AAA Central Penn
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

AAA Central Penn in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, offers both one-time policy consultations and ongoing coverage management for homeowner insurance needs. Local agents help select protection for the property structure, personal belongings, and liability exposures. Plans typically address risks from fire, theft, and weather events common to central Pennsylvania. Adjustments to deductibles and coverage limits are available during annual reviews or after life changes. This agency provides service on an as-needed basis, whether for a new policy purchase, a claim question, or a routine coverage update.

MC
19 Brookwood Ave #102
Miller Carlisle Insurance Services
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Miller Carlisle Insurance Services serves homeowners in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding Cumberland County communities. The agency handles a full range of home insurance policies designed to protect single-family homes, townhouses, and condominiums. It frequently reviews dwelling coverage limits to keep pace with local construction costs and rising material prices in the area. For each client, the agency takes a consultative approach, comparing multiple coverage options side by side before recommending a plan that fits that specific property and budget.

DC
22 S Hanover St
Dan Collison - State Farm Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Dan Collison - State Farm Agent in Carlisle, PA offers homeowners insurance policies that protect residential property and personal belongings. The agency assists local residents with general insurance needs, including liability coverage and policy reviews. Helping clients understand deductibles and coverage limits during the home-buying process is a common service. This agent also addresses concerns related to winter weather risks, such as frozen pipes and ice dam damage, which often affect homes in the Carlisle area.

DI
26 Westminster Dr
Deibler Insurance Associates
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Deibler Insurance Associates serves Carlisle, Pennsylvania, as a local home insurance agent. Unlike a one-time purchase, home insurance typically renews annually to maintain continuous property protection. Coverage generally safeguards the dwelling and personal belongings against common perils such as fire, theft, and weather damage, with options for added liability protection. Policyholders can select specific deductibles and coverage limits to match their individual needs and budget. Service for obtaining or adjusting this insurance operates on a scheduled basis, for each renewal cycle.

GF
155 W High St
Grove Financial &Associates, Inc.
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

As winter weather approaches in Carlisle, homeowners often find themselves reviewing coverage for potential ice and snow damage. Grove Financial & Associates, Inc. provides home insurance guidance to help local property owners protect their dwellings and personal belongings against such common seasonal risks. They offer policies that address typical needs in the area, including protection for structural damage and liability from accidents on the premises. An initial consultation or inspection of the home is typically scheduled to assess coverage requirements and necessary limits for the property.

IC
43 Eastgate Dr Suite 100
Insurance Connections / Benefit Connections - aka The Kole Group
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA

Insurance Connections / Benefit Connections, also known as The Kole Group, provides residential home insurance services to homeowners in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Their offerings also extend to commercial coverage for local businesses and properties. The agency serves clients throughout the Carlisle area. Customers can request follow-up service or schedule repeat visits between regular policy reviews to update their coverage as needs change.

DE
1786 Newville Rd
Douglas E. Garrity Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA
SA
95 Alexander Spring Rd #1
Strickler Agency Inc
Home Insurance Agent · Carlisle, PA
(717) 243-2921
stricklerins.com

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Carlisle Cost?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Pennsylvania is about 1,200 to 1,800 dollars per year for a standard policy. In Carlisle costs may vary based on your homes value and proximity to fire stations. Older homes or those with outdated systems may have higher premiums. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Carlisle

A home insurance agent in Carlisle Pennsylvania can help you find a policy that protects your property and meets state requirements. Pennsylvania law does not require homeowners insurance but mortgage lenders typically do. Agents in Carlisle understand local risks like winter weather and can explain coverage options for your specific situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Carlisle do?

A home insurance agent helps you compare policies from different insurance companies. They explain coverage types such as dwelling protection liability and personal property. They also assist with filing claims and adjusting your policy as your needs change.

How do I choose a home insurance agent in Carlisle Pennsylvania?

Look for an agent who is licensed by the Pennsylvania Insurance Department. You can verify a license on the department website. Ask about their experience with homes in Carlisle and whether they offer policies from multiple carriers.

What factors affect home insurance cost in Carlisle?

Costs depend on your homes age location construction type and claims history. Pennsylvania law allows insurers to consider your credit score. Other factors include the amount of coverage you choose and your deductible amount.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.