ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsWisconsin › Middleton

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Middleton, WI

Browse health insurance agents serving Middleton, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Middleton, Wisconsin is The Health Insurance Store, rated 5.0 stars across 1,125 reviews. Other highly rated options include Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent, Compliance Insurance, Baer Insurance Services, Inc.. This directory lists 17 health insurance agents serving Middleton.

Showing 17 health insurance agents in Middleton, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1The Health Insurance Store7447 University Ave Suite 204(608) 210-2500
2Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent6924 University Ave(608) 831-2886
3Compliance Insurance8383 Greenway Blvd 6th Floor, Ste 600(608) 836-1001
4Baer Insurance Services, Inc.9701 Brader Way Suite 101(608) 830-5800
5AVID Risk Solutions2501 Parmenter St #200a(608) 827-4525
6Schwarz Insurance Agency6605 University Ave Suite 202(608) 831-9660
7Northwestern Mutual1600 Aspen Commons #800(608) 836-3080
8Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance1468 N High Point Rd # 101(608) 831-1800
9Daniel Olson American Family Insurance1833 Parmenter St(608) 836-4200
10Brian Kelly Agency, LLC American Family Insurance6700 University Ave(608) 831-2525
HI
7447 University Ave Suite 204
The Health Insurance Store
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

The Health Insurance Store serves the Middleton, Wisconsin area as a local health insurance agent. The agency helps individuals and families navigate plan options during open enrollment and special enrollment periods. They offer guidance on comparing coverage levels for medical, dental, and vision needs. The firm also assists small business owners in selecting group health benefits for their employees. In this area, they commonly handle Medicare Supplement plans and Affordable Care Act marketplace policies.

AA
6924 University Ave
Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middleton, WI provides a range of health insurance options designed to protect individuals and families. The agency helps clients select appropriate plans and manage ongoing coverage needs through personalized service and regular policy reviews. Its service plans focus on assessing changing healthcare requirements and adjusting coverage accordingly. Policyholders receive support with claims and benefit questions throughout the year. The agency regularly services single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants in the local area.

CI
8383 Greenway Blvd 6th Floor, Ste 600
Compliance Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Homeowners and business owners in Middleton, Wisconsin turn to Compliance Insurance for professional health insurance agent services. These licensed agents evaluate individual coverage needs, compare available plans, and assist clients during open enrollment periods. The agency also explains the differences between Health Savings Accounts and traditional medical plans for both families and local employers. With an appointment, clients can review policy details tailored to their medical needs and financial situations. This health insurance agent extends its services into the neighboring communities of Madison and Verona.

BI
9701 Brader Way Suite 101
Baer Insurance Services, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Baer Insurance Services, Inc. serves clients in and around the city of Middleton, Wisconsin, and its surrounding communities. The company handles health insurance plans for individuals, families, and groups, focusing on coverage options that comply with local and federal regulations. To handle a typical client’s needs, it first assesses each individual’s healthcare requirements and budget before comparing available policies from different carriers to find a suitable fit.

AR
2501 Parmenter St #200a
AVID Risk Solutions
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

AVID Risk Solutions serves clients in Middleton, WI, by clarifying the difference between one-time enrollment assistance for a single plan selection and ongoing service options that support annual changes. As an independent health insurance agent, the company helps individuals and families navigate available coverage choices in the local market, focusing on plan benefits and network details. These services are provided on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to request guidance whenever a policy decision or coverage question arises.

SI
6605 University Ave Suite 202
Schwarz Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Schwarz Insurance Agency in Middleton, Wisconsin, assists individuals and families in finding health insurance coverage that meets their medical needs and financial situations. The agency helps clients navigate plan options during open enrollment and qualifying life events. Their work includes explaining policy details, comparing deductibles, and coordinating with major carriers to secure suitable plans. Schwarz Insurance Agency serves a range of local commercial sectors, including small professional offices, retail warehouses, and food service establishments.

NM
1600 Aspen Commons #800
Northwestern Mutual
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

As open enrollment season brings families in Middleton to review their coverage options, Northwestern Mutual provides guidance as a health insurance agent. Navigating plan changes and local network details requires a clear explanation of benefits. The company works with area residents to compare policies, confirming which doctors and prescriptions are covered. Before recommending a specific plan, the agent first reviews the client's current coverage and medical needs through a complete initial assessment.

JE
1468 N High Point Rd # 101
Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Jeff Engelkes Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance serves residential clients in Middleton with health insurance policies that help cover medical expenses and preventive care. The agency also provides commercial health coverage for local business owners and their employees throughout the Middleton area. Agents work with individuals and families to select plans that fit their needs and budgets. After a policy is in place, the office remains available for follow‑up service, including claims assistance and plan adjustments between regular annual visits.

DO
1833 Parmenter St
Daniel Olson American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI

Daniel Olson American Family Insurance serves Middleton, Wisconsin, as a local health insurance agent. The agency assists individuals and families in selecting medical coverage plans that fit their needs and budget. Work involves explaining plan benefits, enrollment windows, and network options to clients in the Madison area. Navigating open enrollment or life changes can be complex, so the agent helps clarify choices from available policies. For clients who also need protection for unexpected medical costs, the agency can add short-term health insurance coverage as a supplemental option.

BK
6700 University Ave
Brian Kelly Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
PI
8333 Greenway Blvd Ste 200
Progressive Insurance - Claims Office
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(800) 776-4737
progressive.com/claims
PI
2421 Parmenter St
Petersburg Insurance Agency LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 824-7267
c4ins.com
RI
1818 Parmenter St #300
Riesen Insurance Agency, LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 225-3523
teamriesen.com
PI
6728 Frank Lloyd Wright Ave
Prizm Insurance & Risk Services
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 960-7950
prizminsurance.com
GN
6810 University Ave
Greene-Niesen Insurance Agency, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 831-3168
greeneniesen.com
GI
2501 Parmenter St #200a
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(608) 827-4525
locations.ajg.com/us/wi/middleton/2501-parmenter-street
IH
1600 Aspen Commons #600
Independent Health Care Plan (iCare)
Health Insurance Agent · Middleton, WI
(800) 777-4376
icarehealthplan.org

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Middleton Cost?

Health insurance agents in Wisconsin do not charge you directly for their help. Their compensation comes from the insurance carriers. Plan premiums vary widely based on age, income, and coverage level. For example, a mid level ACA plan for a 40 year old in Dane County may cost between 400 and 700 dollars per month before subsidies. Subsidies can lower that amount significantly. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Middleton

Health insurance agents in Middleton, Wisconsin help individuals and families find coverage through the Health Insurance Marketplace, Medicare, and private plans. Wisconsin law requires agents to be licensed by the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance. Agents can explain plan options, subsidies, and enrollment periods for Dane County residents.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a health insurance agent in Middleton do?

A health insurance agent helps you compare plans from different carriers. They can explain Wisconsin specific rules like BadgerCare eligibility and open enrollment dates. Agents do not charge a fee for their services as they are paid by the insurance company.

When can I enroll in a health plan in Wisconsin?

The annual Open Enrollment Period for ACA plans runs from November 1 to January 15 in Wisconsin. Special Enrollment Periods are available after qualifying life events like marriage, birth, or loss of other coverage. Medicare enrollment has separate initial and annual periods.

Do I need a local agent if I buy online?

A local Middleton agent can help you understand how plans work with local providers like UW Health and SSM Health. They can also assist with Wisconsin specific programs such as the Wisconsin Health Insurance Risk Sharing Plan. Local knowledge can make plan selection easier.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.