ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Butler, PA

Browse health insurance agents serving Butler, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Butler, Pennsylvania is Baker Consulting Services, Inc., rated 5.0 stars across 235 reviews. Other highly rated options include John E Hollock Insurance Agency, Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc., AAdvantage Insurance Services. This directory lists 19 health insurance agents serving Butler.

Showing 19 health insurance agents in Butler, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Baker Consulting Services, Inc.124 S Washington St(724) 302-3164
2John E Hollock Insurance Agency506 N Main St(724) 283-3897
3Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.340 N McKean St(724) 283-2260
4AAdvantage Insurance Services1723 N Main St Ext(724) 287-3743
5C. W. Howard Insurance405 W Jefferson St(724) 283-8181
6Raisley Insurance1120 N Main St Ext(724) 287-7757
7Gwen Sciullo - State Farm Insurance Agent293 Evans City Rd(724) 285-3259
8Health Benefit Options340 N Main St(724) 705-0068
9Kotch Insurance Agency201 S Duffy Rd(724) 285-1164
10Health Management Brokers614 Moraine Pointe Plaza(724) 822-0388
BC
124 S Washington St
Baker Consulting Services, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Baker Consulting Services, Inc. serves the Butler, Pennsylvania metro area as a health insurance agent. It helps individuals and families navigate available health coverage plans. The agency works with clients to assess their medical needs and financial situations. These evaluations assist in finding suitable policy options from major carriers in the region. Open enrollment periods are a focused time for guidance. It specifically handles plan comparisons and enrollment assistance for local residents.

JE
506 N Main St
John E Hollock Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

John E Hollock Insurance Agency assists homeowners, renters, and local business owners in securing health insurance coverage tailored to their specific needs. The agency works with individuals to navigate plan options, including individual and family policies, and helps employers find group health benefits for their staff. It is located in Butler, Pennsylvania, and also serves clients in the greater Pittsburgh metropolitan area.

TR
340 N McKean St
Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc. offers a range of health insurance options, including individual and family plans, and provides ongoing service to help clients manage their coverage and address policy changes throughout the year. The company assists with plan updates and customer support for claims and billing questions. It services the Butler, PA, area, covering households, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants.

AI
1723 N Main St Ext
AAdvantage Insurance Services
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

AAdvantage Insurance Services serves the Butler, Pennsylvania area and surrounding communities in western Pennsylvania. The agency handles health insurance needs for individuals, families, and small business owners. This includes helping clients select major medical plans, Medicare options, and supplemental coverage. The agency takes a consultative approach to each case, beginning with a thorough review of the client's specific healthcare needs and budget to identify suitable policies from multiple carriers.

CW
405 W Jefferson St
C. W. Howard Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Specialty services from C. W. Howard Insurance include helping individuals navigate the individual marketplace plans available through the Affordable Care Act, along with assisting families in selecting appropriate coverage for their household. As a health insurance agent serving Butler, PA, the company also guides clients through Medicare supplement options and short-term policies. During the open enrollment period each fall, it helps local residents compare plans and adjust their coverage for the coming year.

RI
1120 N Main St Ext
Raisley Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Residents needing help with health insurance can choose between one-time policy guidance and ongoing enrollment support. As a local health insurance agent in Butler, PA, this company helps individuals and families understand coverage options available through private plans and public marketplaces. The agent explains plan details, helps compare benefits, and assists with applications. Service for health insurance needs is available on an as-needed basis, whether during open enrollment periods or when life changes require updating coverage.

GS
293 Evans City Rd
Gwen Sciullo - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

As the seasonal open enrollment period approaches each year in Butler, many residents begin reviewing their coverage options. Gwen Sciullo, operating as a State Farm Insurance Agent, offers health insurance consultations in the local area. The agency helps individuals and families who are navigating plan changes or seeking new policies to meet their medical needs. Clients can schedule an appointment to discuss preferred networks and prescription coverage. The process begins with an initial assessment of current health care requirements during a complimentary office visit.

HB
340 N Main St
Health Benefit Options
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Health Benefit Options works with clients in Butler, Pennsylvania, to provide guidance on selecting appropriate health coverage plans. While its core focus remains health insurance, the company can assist with optional supplemental policies that address specific medical needs not covered by standard plans. Navigating the complexities of open enrollment periods and plan comparisons is a regular part of its service. The agency serves a range of commercial settings, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

KI
201 S Duffy Rd
Kotch Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Kotch Insurance Agency offers health insurance services to residences in Butler, Pennsylvania, helping individuals find appropriate medical coverage. The agency also assists businesses with commercial health plans for their employees in the local area. An agent works with clients to compare policies and navigate enrollment. Between regular visits, the agency follows up on claims and policy questions to ensure coverage remains aligned with changing needs.

HM
614 Moraine Pointe Plaza
Health Management Brokers
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Health Management Brokers is a health insurance agent in Butler, Pennsylvania, known for helping individuals and families find suitable coverage. Its service range includes comparing major medical plans from various carriers and assisting with Medicare options. The agency guides clients through the application process and helps explain the differences between plan types. It specializes in reconciling the annual open enrollment period with marketplace regulations. An additional service the company can provide is consultations for short-term health insurance as a gap solution.

WA
260 New Castle Rd
The West Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 282-4089
thewestagency.net
MI
230 Mercer St
Minich Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 285-3743
minichinsurance.com
SI
1109 N Main St Ext
Siegel Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 209-1575
siegelinsurance.net
MI
400 N Main St
Mitchell Insurance, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 283-7900
since1849.com
HI
127 E Cunningham St
Harrison Insurance Broker
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 602-5689
bizzins.com
7M
10 Pittsburgh Rd
724 Medicare
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 276-5019
724medicare.com
CG
101 E Diamond St #215
Core Guard Insurance Pennsylvania
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(878) 201-4221
BI
103 2nd Ave
BRR Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
KI
201 S Duffy Rd
KM Insurance Group
Health Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 524-7604
kmigllc.com

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Butler Cost?

Health insurance agents in Pennsylvania are typically paid by insurance carriers, so their services are free to you. Plan premiums vary widely based on age, income, and plan type. For example, an ACA marketplace plan for a 40-year-old in Butler may cost between 300 and 600 dollars per month before subsidies. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Butler

Health insurance agents in Butler, Pennsylvania help individuals and families find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Pennsylvania law requires all agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict regulations under the Pennsylvania Insurance Department. Local agents understand the specific health insurance options available in Butler County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a health insurance agent in Butler do?

A health insurance agent helps you compare plans from different carriers during open enrollment or special enrollment periods. They explain coverage details, deductibles, and out-of-pocket costs. Agents do not charge you a fee; they are paid by the insurance company.

Can a health insurance agent help with Medicare in Pennsylvania?

Yes, many agents in Butler are certified to sell Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare Supplement plans, and Part D prescription drug plans. Pennsylvania has a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you are 65 and enrolled in Part B.

How do I verify an agent license in Pennsylvania?

You can check an agent license status on the Pennsylvania Insurance Department website. Licensed agents must complete continuing education each year. Working with a licensed agent ensures you are protected by state consumer laws.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.