ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsCalifornia › Santa Maria

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Santa Maria, CA

Browse auto insurance agents serving Santa Maria, California. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Santa Maria, California is Donna Randolph - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 216 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cost-U-Less Insurance, Glenna Ledbetter Insurance, Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Santa Maria.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Santa Maria, CAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Donna Randolph - State Farm Insurance Agent1650 S Broadway(805) 925-4610
2Cost-U-Less Insurance401 N Broadway Ste 1(805) 250-0605
3Glenna Ledbetter Insurance440 E Clark Ave(805) 937-4516
4Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service1523 S Broadway Ste A&B(805) 991-4200
5Allstate Insurance: Premier Blue Insurance Solutions, Inc1640 N Broadway(805) 349-9141
6Allstate Insurance Agent: Santa Maria Insurance Agency, Inc.125 E Stowell Rd STE 101(805) 922-5551
7AAA Santa Maria Insurance and Member Services2033 S Broadway(805) 922-5731
8Antonio Mendoza - State Farm Insurance Agent1103 E Clark Ave Ste D(805) 354-5886
9Michelle Horenberger: Allstate Insurance2125 S Broadway STE 105(805) 348-1665
10Farmers Insurance - Andy Cortez2646 Santa Maria Way Ste 105(805) 934-1300
DR
1650 S Broadway
Donna Randolph - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

Donna Randolph - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Santa Maria, California, area. The agency provides auto insurance coverage for local drivers, protecting vehicles and managing liability risks on busy Central Coast roads. It tailors policies to meet individual driving needs and budgets. Common services include assistance with collision coverage, comprehensive protection against weather or theft, and liability options for bodily injury or property damage. This office handles claims support and policy adjustments for customers throughout the Santa Maria region.

CU
401 N Broadway Ste 1
Cost-U-Less Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

As the harvest season approaches in Santa Maria, many local drivers begin reassessing their coverage needs for farm vehicles or commutes through Central Coast fog. Cost-U-Less Insurance provides auto insurance agent services to meet these shifting requirements for residents across the surrounding area. Their team can help customers evaluate various liability and collision coverage options suitable for different driving conditions common in California. Advising on policy limits and deductibles is a typical part of the process, beginning with a thorough review of the driver’s vehicle and personal insurance history.

GL
440 E Clark Ave
Glenna Ledbetter Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

Homeowners and drivers in Santa Maria, California turn to Glenna Ledbetter Insurance for their auto insurance coverage needs. The agency assists clients in selecting appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive policies tailored to their driving habits and vehicles. Resourceful agents explain coverage options and help customers understand their protection levels while navigating claim processes. This independent agency serves the greater Santa Maria Valley, including nearby communities such as Orcutt and the broader North Santa Barbara County area.

FA
1523 S Broadway Ste A&B
Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service serves the Santa Maria, California area by helping clients find appropriate automobile coverage. The agency can offer specialty add-ons such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement to tailor a policy to individual needs. Personal auto plans are available for daily drivers, while commercial coverage addresses vehicles used for business. The company can provide options for standard office environments, warehouses requiring fleet policies, and food service operations that depend on delivery vehicles.

AI
1640 N Broadway
Allstate Insurance: Premier Blue Insurance Solutions, Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

Allstate Insurance: Premier Blue Insurance Solutions, Inc serves the Santa Maria area and its surrounding communities. As an auto insurance agent, it handles personal and commercial vehicle coverage policies. This includes options for liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. The company works directly with clients to assess individual driving needs and risk factors. To complete a typical job, it compares available coverage plans and presents customized recommendations during a consultation.

AI
125 E Stowell Rd STE 101
Allstate Insurance Agent: Santa Maria Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

When seeking auto insurance, a customer may choose between a one-time policy for a single vehicle or recurring service that adjusts coverage as household needs change. Allstate Insurance Agent: Santa Maria Insurance Agency, Inc. in Santa Maria, CA helps local drivers select appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive plans for their vehicles. Their advisors explain how different deductibles affect monthly payments and out-of-pocket costs during a claim. Service for prospective clients is provided on an as-needed basis through individual appointments or walk-in consultations.

AS
2033 S Broadway
AAA Santa Maria Insurance and Member Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

AAA Santa Maria Insurance and Member Services provides a range of coverage options from its location in Santa Maria, CA, acting as an auto insurance agent for area drivers. Its service approach includes assistance with policy adjustments and claims support designed to help maintain continuous protection. The agency structures its maintenance plans to address changing coverage requirements over time. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants.

AM
1103 E Clark Ave Ste D
Antonio Mendoza - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

As an auto insurance agent in Santa Maria, Antonio Mendoza - State Farm Insurance Agent provides specialty services including coverage for liability, collision, and comprehensive claims. The agency also assists local drivers with routine policy adjustments and claims filing for repairs or vehicle damage. It helps residents in the Santa Maria area manage their insurance needs with personalized options for different driving situations. When season changes bring wet road conditions or higher fire risk in nearby areas, it guides clients through adjusting their coverage for added protection.

MH
2125 S Broadway STE 105
Michelle Horenberger: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

As the Central Coast’s variable weather can suddenly affect driving conditions, Michelle Horenberger: Allstate Insurance in Santa Maria helps local drivers adjust their auto coverage to match seasonal risks, such as increased rain or tourists navigating unfamiliar roads. The agency reviews each client’s unique driving habits and vehicle usage to tailor liability and comprehensive options. An initial inspection of the car and a review of the customer’s driving record form the first step toward a personalized policy.

FI
2646 Santa Maria Way Ste 105
Farmers Insurance - Andy Cortez
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA

Farmers Insurance - Andy Cortez offers auto insurance to residents in and around Santa Maria, California. Coverage is available for personal vehicles as well as commercial automobiles for local businesses in the area. The agency provides service to drivers throughout Santa Maria and the surrounding communities. Clients can schedule a consultation to review their current policies or request new quotes specific to their driving needs. After an initial policy setup, the agent often follows up to check satisfaction and adjusts coverage during regular visits as circumstances change.

FA
1115 W Main St F
Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 888-8881
fiestainsurance.com/stores/fiesta-insurance-and-tax-santa-maria-california-ca124
PE
1750 S Broadway H
Pacific Elite Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 357-5597
paceliteins.com
SI
1975 S Broadway Suite K
Smartway Insurance Services Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 631-5255
savewithsmartway.com
CH
526 E Mill St
California Heritage Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 925-0020
calheritageins.com
ES
830 W Main St suite 100
Eagle Service Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 346-6105
eagleserviceins.com
LI
415 S Broadway
LATINOS INSURANCE AGENCY
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 862-4904
latinosinsurances.com
SS
612 S Broadway
Smart Stop Insurance Services
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 925-6200
smartstopinsurance.com
CA
121 N Broadway
Coast Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 925-1990
coastautoinsurance.com
AO
326 W Main St Suite 220
Alpha & Omega Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 354-0031
alphaomegabk.com
CS
2236 S Broadway k
California Star Insurance Service, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Santa Maria, CA
(805) 266-7971
calstarins.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Santa Maria Cost?

Auto insurance costs in Santa Maria vary based on factors like driving record, age, vehicle type, and coverage level. Average annual premiums in California range from about $1,200 for minimum coverage to over $2,500 for full coverage. Drivers with accidents or tickets may pay higher rates. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Santa Maria

Auto insurance agents in Santa Maria, California help drivers find coverage that meets state legal requirements. California law mandates minimum liability limits of 15/30/5, meaning $15,000 per person and $30,000 per accident for bodily injury, plus $5,000 for property damage. A local agent can explain these requirements and help you choose additional options like collision or comprehensive coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the minimum auto insurance coverage required in California?

California requires all drivers to carry liability insurance with minimum limits of 15/30/5. This covers $15,000 for injury or death of one person, $30,000 total per accident, and $5,000 for property damage. An agent can help you understand if higher limits are advisable for your situation.

Do I need an SR-22 form in Santa Maria?

An SR-22 is a certificate of financial responsibility required for drivers with certain violations like DUI or driving without insurance. In California, you must file an SR-22 with the DMV for three years. An auto insurance agent in Santa Maria can help you obtain this filing from your insurer.

Can I get auto insurance with a suspended license in California?

Yes, you can still purchase auto insurance in California with a suspended license, though options may be limited. Many insurers require a valid license, but some companies offer policies for drivers with suspensions. An agent can help you find a carrier that accepts your situation.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other California Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.